Sunday, March 29, 2020

CORONA---Further Thoughts


          Personally, I have never been happier to be working at my dreary job in a big-box store than I am now.  If I were not working, I would be seriously worried as we descend into this government-mandated economic nightmare.  In a way, I think this will be like the Great Depression.  If you ask people who lived through it what it was like, they often say, “Well, if you had a job, you were OK.”  This may be much the same story.

          Also, if I were just sitting home watching the world collapse around me, it would drive me nuts.

*

          Prediction: a month from now, the frenzy and panic over a shortage of ventilators will be an embarrassment to those who engaged in it.

*

          I frequently hear (in a condescending tone), that people are being silly to empty store shelves of  toilet paper, bread, eggs, and other commodities.  “There’s plenty of trees, wheat, chickens---why are people doing this?”

          It seems perfectly reasonable to me.  Every day, the TV and the newspapers crank up the fear one more notch and consign any encouraging news to page 23.  Why would it be surprising that ordinary citizens would fear martial law, a complete breakdown of order, draconian isolation orders, and being locked in their homes for the next six months?  That’s pretty much what we are being led to believe every day, so why wouldn’t you want a stockpile of TP?

*

          Speaking of toilet paper, the corona panic again teaches us the foolishness of so-called “anti-gouging laws,” though politicians never seem to get the message.

          If prices were allowed to respond to demand, there would be no hoarding because nobody would buy more toilet paper than he needed.  If it cost $10 for a 4-pack, you would buy ONE 4-pack, and you would only do it if you truly needed it.  Very soon, as consumers saw there was no shortage, prices would drop back down to normal levels.

          Prices carry information about markets.  This is the purpose of the price system.  Periodically, when there is a hurricane in South Florida, plywood will become scarce and the price (if it is allowed to), will triple.  When that happens, all that plywood sitting idly at Home Depots in Georgia somehow jumps onto trucks and winds up in Miami a day later.  Magic.

          Does America need more ventilators?  If so, threatening GM, and demanding production at cost or below is the wrong way to get them.  Instead, publish the specs for what is needed, suspend all regulations that restrain the market, and get out of the way.

*

          In addition to the numbers of corona cases and deaths that make our headlines every day (by state, by city, by zip code), shouldn’t we be seeing numbers of those who died yesterday from our seasonal flu?

*

          Dissent or resistance from the program of mandatory business and school shut-downs is drawing an increasing level of police power from the mayors and governors and others who are determined to keep us unemployed and sheltered in place.  Now there are snitch-on-your-neighbor hotlines and cops knocking on doors.  One reason dissent cannot be tolerated is that if an area stayed open and experienced the same amount of corona pain as a locked-down area, it would throw serious doubt on the efficacy of the social distancing rules being imposed.  Those who would use the public-health rationale for these unprecedented incursions on our basic human rights cannot allow those types of questions to be asked.

Copyright2020MichaelKubacki

Thursday, March 19, 2020

MY NATION GONE MAD---Reflections on the Coronavirus



          As I write this, on March 16, 2020, the city of Philadelphia has just announced that one may not eat in a restaurant or have a drink in a bar until further notice.  The Governor of this state made a similar decree a couple days ago regarding the four counties surrounding Philly.  Ditto the Governor of New Jersey regarding all of Jersey.  I believe there are bars open in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, about 65 miles away, but there is no guarantee they will still be open when I get there.  Wilmington, Delaware is a bit closer, only 35 miles away, but with all the internets and Googles in the world, I can’t seem to find out what the rules are down there.  The trip to Wilmington is not that pleasant under the best of circumstances, but to go there looking for a Miller High Life and find the bars are closed, well, I’m not sure I could handle it emotionally.

          So I’ll rant instead.

          When was the first time you heard the term “social distancing?”  For me, it was about three weeks ago and I didn’t understand what it meant at first, did you?  Your first thought was probably that it meant you were supposed to stay away from sick people so you don’t get sick or, if you were sick, to stay away from healthy people so you wouldn’t infect them.  I know a bunch of old people and if I have a cough or a tickle in the throat, I stay away from them.  It’s just courtesy.  It’s common sense.

          But that’s not what social distancing means.  Now it means not allowing young, healthy people to congregate because even though they are not sick and are unlikely to get sick, they might pick up a germ from some other young, healthy person at the school or the restaurant or the Billie Eilish concert or an NCAA basketball game or the Coachella Festival, and carry that germ back to grandma or the old lady across the street.  So it’s important to ban all but the most essential social interactions among completely healthy people because if somebody carries a Coronavirus back to an 86-year-old sick person with a respiratory problem and a weak immune system, she might die. 

          OK.  Then why don’t we do this every Fall and Winter to stop those who are well-stricken in years from dying of the flu?  Flu kills about 40,000 a year in the U.S., so if we just ban all concerts and basketball games and the NHL and close all the restaurants and bars from say, September to June, that would save all or most of our elderly flu victims from dying, wouldn’t it?  We could still sneak in a baseball game or two and a backyard party in July and August.  You could even book a cruise.

          It’s an interesting theory, this mandatory “social distancing.”  Plausible, to a point.  And as we have seen, it’s possible to hang lots of anecdotes on it, like ornaments on a Christmas tree.  (Have you heard about Patient 31?)

          Now, as a possible alternative to banning everything, you might tell those kids who went to the Billie Eilish concert that there’s a bad bug floating around so they shouldn’t visit their 86-year-old sick grandma with the respiratory problem and the weak immune system for a little while after the concert but….  Well, no.  We can’t just advise people to behave responsibly because, you know, we just can’t.  I mean, what if they don’t?  What if they don’t listen to geniuses like Donald Trump and Mike Pence and Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer and Andrew Cuomo who know what’s best for everybody?  So let’s just close all the restaurants and bars and cancel all sports events indefinitely and put millions of people out of work and shut down vacation spots like Vegas and Disney so all those people lose their jobs and cut everybody’s 401k in half and plunge the nation into what will likely be a prolonged recession because we KNOW this “social distancing” thing will work and will stop this virus because it worked when we used it on….

          On what, exactly?  What disease did we shut down by shutting down civil society and all its institutions?  The flu?  Well, no.  We never try it with the flu.  Ebola?  Un-uh.  I don’t remember anybody missing a Yankees game for the Ebola social distancing campaign.  What about H1N1, the swine flu?  That killed a bunch of people!  But no.  The US government didn’t really do anything about swine flu until it was mostly over, and then a few schools were closed, but it didn’t seem to make much difference.

          But now suddenly, “social distancing” is the answer.  Because it’s science, right?  I mean, nobody is allowed to even question it.  It’s like one of those laws laid down by Isaac Newton even though it’s never been tried before and most of us never heard of it before.

          The primary “authority” for this scheme appears to be an article that appeared in 2007 involving a study of the 1918 Spanish Flu epidemic.  Looking back ninety years at death records, medical accounts, newspaper clippings and such, the study concluded that the Spanish flu hit harder in some cities where population density was higher and people routinely had more contact with each other. The article noted a higher death rate in Philadelphia than St. Louis because, the authors believed, Philly had a large St. Patrick’s Day Parade and St. Louis didn’t.  This article was published in JAMA, the Journal of the American Medical Association, a publication that in recent years has not seen a central-government, top-down, mandatory public health plan it didn’t like.

          And that is pretty much where the “science” comes from. Where else could it come from?  It’s not like “social distancing” has been studied because we’ve never tried it before.  We never really tried to shut down American culture, industry, social life, schools, sports, movies, travel, and the financial world to stop a virus.

          There’s other articles too, of course, and there are plenty of computer models for the spread of disease.  The models are fun, and they have simulations where infected ping-pongs balls and healthy ping-pong balls start bouncing around and hitting each other, and then eventually there are some ping-pong balls that have recovered from whatever the disease was and they start bouncing around too.  And then, I think, we all die.

          Yes, I’m making fun of the “science” because there isn’t very much of it.  But that’s not really my point.  I like science.  I respect the work of scientists.  And there are serious scientists who think “social distancing” might be a good way to limit the effects of the Coronavirus.  But that doesn’t mean mandatory social distancing will be effective, that it will “work.”  There’s no evidence for that position, but I don’t blame some scientists for thinking it might.

          But in our complex society, as all of us know, there are no solutions, there are only tradeoffs, so why are we not permitted to consider what the tradeoffs will be?  Why have our political leaders not even mentioned them?  Why is there no serious discussion of this in newspapers or on TV?  WE HAVE NEVER DONE THIS BEFORE, FOR ANY REASON.  And it is already having terrible consequences.

          There will be people, millions of them, who lose their jobs or their businesses or their livelihoods, so there will be evictions and foreclosures.  Some will be made homeless, and there will be divorces, and some will be separated from their children.  There will be suicides.  It’s what happens in a severe recession, or an economic depression.  There will be people (there already are), who lose most of their savings and will face a more perilous retirement.  Some of them may die prematurely, much like the elderly victims of Corona.  We know these victims will exist, but we will not know their names.  We will know the names, and the number, of those who die from Corona, but we will not know the unnamed people whose lives are ruined, or shortened, from the draconian efforts being made to stop it.
         
          Why?  Why can’t this issue even be raised in the public square?  I know it can’t because I have tried to raise it online, and in a community forum, and even with friends, and I have been met with rage just for asking the question. Here’s the new rule: if Corona might infect an old person with serious medical problems and kill them, the way many other diseases and conditions are known to do, we must now shut down society in order to protect ourselves and the elderly person from getting Corona even if the harm we inflict on ourselves dwarfs the danger we face from the virus itself.

          In no way am I attempting to minimize the potential danger this disease represents, and the hard choices it may entail for individuals trying to live their lives.  That is the human condition and it always has been.  So if it’s your granny who is 86 and has cancer, you may have to hide her away in an upstairs bedroom until the danger passes.  But your fears and my fears cannot justify shutting down life in America for honest, decent people who are just trying to live their lives, educate their kids, make a dollar or two, and go to the movies once a month. 

          The reason we may not question the destruction of civil society for the sake of stopping Corona is not because of the virus itself but because of who we are and what we have become.  For years, as a society, we have seen the emergence of an ethos founded in the idea that any visible danger must be eliminated no matter the cost.  If anyone might have an allergic reaction to peanuts, peanuts must be banned.  If an unpopular idea might be expressed and upset some listeners, the speaker must be silenced.  Your child car seat must be approved by all authorized government agencies or you can be punished.  Let your 8-year-old ride his bike around the block by himself and the authorities might take him away from you.

          The Precautionary Principle has won, and our response to this virus is perfectly in keeping with our surrender to the health-and-safety police. Allowing reason, or a balancing of costs and benefits, into the calculus would discount the validity of fear as the deciding principle, and that can no longer be permitted. 

          Our nation, with a lot of help from our political leaders and our media, has gone mad with fear, which is now the basis of our most important decisions in public policy.  Real dangers exist, but we are not addressing them in any methodical and rational way.  Like helicopter parents, we are not really solving any problems, we are merely giving in to our anxieties.  So far, that has been the primary effect of the Coronavirus---it has turned us into our own helicopter parents.



Copyright2020MichaelKubacki        

Monday, March 2, 2020

A Theory On Coronavirus


Here’s three facts about the spread, so far, of this disease:

1) There are a growing number of people who have tested positive for the virus but have no symptoms, and may never show symptoms.

2) The CDC, for complicated and not very interesting reasons, has not had a very reliable test for coronavirus but will have one any day now.

3) For the past two weeks, there has been a coronavirus case in a Sacramento hospital where the person had no known connection with China, the cruise ship in Japan, or any other known source of the disease.

The last of these items has been especially intriguing, at least for me.  What could it mean?  All the other cases in the US are traceable to some specific person or place or airport or restaurant or something, but this particular California poobah has no connection to any of them.  How did she get it?

Well, unless she made her own bat soup, or unless she secretly traveled to Wuhan, China on her hovercraft, got infected and then snuck back into California, she probably got the disease the way California poohbahs always get sick, which is by being in contact with some other California poohbah who is carrying a germ they got from some other California poohbah, and so on and so on and so on.  In other words, there are thousands or tens of thousands of people in California and the rest of America who are carrying this virus around and we just haven’t identified them yet.

And there are two reasons we haven’t identified them yet.  First, the CDC hasn’t been able to identify them because they haven’t had a reliable test for coronavirus.  Once they do, however, which will be any minute now, the American healthcare infrastructure will start identifying these people like the dickens.  We will be the best country in the world at counting all the people with coronavirus because once we get our act in gear, there is nobody more thorough and efficient (and annoying), than America at doing stuff like that.  We’re going to have A LOT of cases.  We could have a hundred thousand positive tests.  There will be a panic, and it will be Trump’s fault, of course, and the stock market will take it on the chin again.  Major selloff.  Another two thousand points on the DJIA.

And at that point, buy.

Remember I said there are two reasons we haven’t identified all our coronavirus cases?  Well, one is the lack of a good test, but the other reason is that most of the people with coronavirus don’t get sick, or they don’t get very sick, and they certainly don’t die.  I can’t verify this, but I don’t think there has been a single child anywhere in the world that has died from corona, and among victims who are young and strong adults, there have been (almost) no fatalities.

Once the full epidemiological profile is known, the panic will end.  Yes, there will be some deaths, but they will be mostly 90-year-olds who already had pneumonia and diabetes.  The flu averages about 40,000 deaths a year in America.  A year from now, will there be 40,000 deaths in America from corona?  If this theory is correct, the number will be far, far less.

Copyright2020MichaelKubacki      

Friday, February 14, 2020

MIKE !


          As I write this, the Iowa Caucuses ended 48 hours ago and we’re expecting the results to roll in somewhere around St. Patrick’s Day, but that’s not what I’ve come here to talk about.

          I’m here because I’m reading and hearing commentary from supposed wise guys and insiders and experts to the effect that the skids are being greased to slip the Democratic nomination to Michael Bloomberg.

          “Mark my words,” they say.  “This is all being set up for Bloomberg behind the scenes.  Don’t doubt me on something like this.  The powers inside the party will not let Bernie win and they can see Biden doesn’t always know what state he’s in, and they already offered it to Michelle Obama but she doesn’t want it, so they decided it’s gonna be Bloomberg and his billions.”

          They’re always so certain.  That’s the tell.

          What makes this type of thing interesting is that the people who do it are not just blowhards, though there are plenty of blowhards who do it too.  Often they will have “insider” credentials and a substantial resume in the politics business.  And there is no reason to believe they are being dishonest.  They’re wrong because they are insiders and they are so deeply embedded in the bubble that they can’t see the world around them has changed.  Louis XVI was the last guy to get the memo about Robespierre and his buddies.  Czar Nicholas II never quite figured out he was going to be the last czar of Russia until, suddenly, he was.

          Hugh Hewitt is a syndicated radio host who seems to know everything there is to know about the Republican Party and elected Republicans.  He knows the names of their wives and their kids, and he knows what percentage they got in the last election and who they beat.  It’s his niche in conservative radio.  He’s a party guy rather than an ideologue.

          A little more than three years ago, he interviewed Jeb at least a dozen times on the radio and made it clear that Bush would quickly rise to the top of the Republican field.  Hugh is sufficiently pan-Republican that he didn’t guarantee a Bush nomination, but there was no doubt where his sympathies were focused, and there was no doubt of his belief that Bush’s nomination was inevitable.  He held this view for months, even as Jeb! spent $125 million winning exactly one delegate.  And he was far from alone in this opinion.  I won money from people who knew the fix was in for Jeb and that he couldn’t be stopped.

          And I am no genius. Tens of millions of Republicans understood from the get-go that after two dreadful, timid candidates like John McCain and (especially) Mitt Romney, a soft-spoken, low-energy reiteration of the Bush family would go nowhere.  It was only insiders who believed in Jeb, along with a few Democrats who had no idea how Republicans think.

          Michael Bloomberg brings the same aroma of “you-must-be-kidding!” to this year’s Democratic race.

          It’s the money, of course.  Bloomberg has spent $250 million on commercials getting himself to the point, at 6% in the national polls, where a lot of people now have a vague sense of who he is.  I guess the idea is that once he spends another $250 million, he will get to 12%, and so on and so on.  About $2.5 billion in TV ads will get him elected in a landslide.  Right?

          Or if that’s not the plan, well, what is the plan?  What Bloomberg’s electoral strategy actually reminds me of is the South Park underwear gnomes.  As you may recall, their 3-step plan to acquire unimaginable riches was as follows:
          1) Steal underwear from celebrities.
          2) ????????????????????????
          3)  Profit!!!

The Bloomberg variation appears to be something similar:
          1) Spend billions showing pictures of yourself talking to African-Americans.
          2) ???????????????????
          3) Be inaugurated president on January 20, 2021!!!

          Money is nice, of course.  Candidates always wish they had more than they do.  But if money could buy the presidency, we would now be in the 4th year of the Hillary administration.  The final numbers from the 2016 election had her spending $768 million to Trump’s $398 million---almost a 2 – 1 ratio.

          In addition, what’s so wonderful about the guy?

          The best thing Bloomberg has going for him at the moment is that all anybody knows about him is the fluff on his TV commercials.  No one has attacked him politically because they haven’t yet taken him seriously.  But that will change.

          For example, whatever happened to all those sexual harassment complaints about Bloomberg?  They always seemed to pop up in the news and then vanish a day or two later.  I wonder if any of those young ladies could be persuaded to come out of the woodwork now that we’re in the age of #MeToo.  More importantly, where “stop-and-frisk” is concerned, Rudy Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg were pretty much Thing 1 and Thing 2 in the Big Apple.  Over the course of 25 years or so, the two of them cut the murder rate in NYC by 85% by concentrating police resources in the areas where murderers were murdering.  For Democrats, of course, this was a VERY BAD THING because, well, it’s racist to stop young black men from murdering other young black men.  (Don’t stare too deeply into the logic of it.)   But once Democratic voters find out Bloomberg prevented all those murders, and that there are thousands of black men still alive in NYC because of Bloomberg’s efforts*, he won’t look nearly so attractive as a candidate.

          Then there’s the China connection that has thus far gotten zero attention in the political press.  Because the reflexive attitude among Dems is to like everything Trump hates (e.g., open borders, gun confiscation, infanticide), it is possible no Democrat will try to attack Bloomberg for his links to Chinese businesses and the Chinese government and his ownership or part ownership of hundreds of Chinese companies.  But Trump will.  Trump will not be at all shy in pointing out that almost all of Bloomberg’s vast wealth can be traced to his Chinese connections, and that it’s probably more accurate to call to him a Chinese billionaire than an American one.

          Plus, he’s short.

          And finally, there’s another Giuliani echo in the Bloomberg story.  Recall, if you will, the 2008 Giuliani campaign for the Republican nomination for president.

          Rudy G was something of a national hero at the time.  He was “America’s Mayor,” the man who had single-handedly shepherded NYC through the horrors and the aftermath of 9-11.  National polls had him atop the field for the nomination, and while early polls don’t necessarily mean much (as we are seeing now), Giuliani was regarded as the front-runner for several months.

          Plotting his strategy, Rudy decided to skip the early votes in places like Iowa and New Hampshire, where his New York persona and manners might not play with the masses, and concentrate on the Florida primary instead.  He spent several months there, and had the state pretty much to himself.  The theory was that Florida (with all its ex-New Yorkers), would love him and that his huge victory in the primary would catapult him to victory in the remaining primaries.

          The problem was that all the news media and all the excitement was in Iowa and New Hampshire, and Giuliani was not, so he was forgotten.  On his big day, the day he had pinned all his hopes upon, he finished third in the Florida voting.  The next day, he dropped out of the race.

          The rules and the primary dates are somewhat different now, compared to 2008, but Bloomberg’s plan to skip the first year of campaigning and the first four states (Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada, and South Carolina), does not have much of a track record.  The only guy to have tried it, Rudy G, went from heir apparent to laughingstock in one day.

          For Bloomberg, that nightmare day could be Super Tuesday, March 3, when delegates in sixteen states are on the line.  Of particular interest will be California with its 416 delegates, which are 22% of those needed to win the Democratic nomination on the first ballot.  The last polls I saw show Bernie Sanders with a healthy lead on the field and Bloomberg still below 10%.  That may change a bit as Bloomberg spends another $100 million buying up Instagram influencers, but does anybody believe Bernie can lose California to Michael Bloomberg?

          And if, following Super Tuesday, the Bernie flag is still flying high while the Bloomberg juggernaut has been somewhat tarnished by its encounter with electoral reality, the myth of Mike’s inevitability suddenly becomes a lot less believable.

          Prediction: the Bloomberg bubble bursts long before the Democratic National Convention.

Copyright2020MichaelKubacki    

            
*Thanks to Ann Coulter for recently making this particular point, that there are thousands of young black men who survived into adulthood in New York because Giuliani and Bloomberg made it extremely inconvenient for other young black men to murder them.     

Friday, January 31, 2020

NFL PLAYOFFS---2020 Superbowl



Kansas City (-1.5) vs. San Francisco

          On January 19, the bubble burst for Tennessee, a good team that will probably contend for a few years to come, but which finally ran into an offense it could not control.  I got that one wrong.

          In the NFC, the 49ers rolled easily over the Packers, scoring 37 points against them for the second time in two months.  I cashed on that one, making my record for these playoffs 5-3.

          During the regular season, KC posted 7.4 Adjusted Yards/Pass, the best in football this year.  Since the 49er’s AYP was merely a respectable 6.6, the system I am using to make these selections tells me to bet the Chiefs.  A difference of 7.4 to 6.6 is significant, and the Chiefs should cover.  That is the call I am making.

          There are always other factors, of course.  For the Conference Championship games, in an effort to determine which teams were “peaking for the playoffs,” I calculated AYP numbers limited to the last six games of the season.  San Fran, in those last six, had achieved an 8.5 AYP while KC’s AYP was a less-impressive 6.2.  Perhaps the 49ers were actually peaking!  Maybe the Chiefs were fading!  On the other hand, Kansas City had won all six of those games by an average margin of 16 points so it was hard to make the case they were falling apart.

          And if defense matters?  Well, SF has an edge.  Their defensive AYP is a stunning 4.1, superior to the Chief’s 4.7.  Beyond the numbers, we all saw what the SF defenders did to the Vikings and the Packers.

          On the other hand, which QB would you rather have?  Jimmy Garoppolo is certainly good enough to win a championship and I expect he will someday.  Mahomes, however, is capable of winning any game all by himself.  If this Superbowl is won by the team with the better quarterback, as most of them are, this is an easy call.  KC, and Mahomes, are better.

          And then finally, there’s the donut boy, with whom most Philadelphians have a complex love/hate relationship.  When he left here after fourteen seasons as head coach of the Eagles, virtually everyone was glad to see him go, despite his winning record in the regular season, despite his (one!) Superbowl appearance, and despite his NFC East titles.  He was extremely fan-unfriendly, he routinely lied to the sporting press, and he looked very much like the kind of coach who would usually go 11-5 in the regular season but would NEVER win a championship.

          He is still that guy.  Philadelphia’s dislike of him has faded now that the Eagles have finally won a Superbowl because the frustration of those lost fourteen seasons has been buried under the joy of victory, and there is probably a majority of Philly fans pulling for Andy to win this thing.

          I am not one of them.  To me, he is still the guy who somehow always finds a way to lose the big one.

          KC is the better team.  Lay the 1.5 points.  If offenses win Superbowls, and great QBs win Superbowls, and Adjusted Yards/Pass is a legitimate predictor of who gets the cheese, then go with KC.  Personally, I will have to limit my betting to a traditional wager against my brother-in-law of one dollar on the coin flip.  In that one, I like heads.

Copyright2020MichaelKubacki       

Thursday, January 30, 2020

IMPEACHMENT---And Crime


          Like most of the American people, I have not been captivated by the grotesque spectacle of this impeachment trial, and I have managed to find things to amuse myself other than observing the attempt by one of our political parties to destroy treasured institutions of our Republic because they don’t like the guy who won the 2016 elections.  Nevertheless, there is one issue that has captured my imagination because just about everybody is getting it wrong.

          This is the question of whether an impeachable offense must be an actual crime.

          The issue is important because the House articles of impeachment do not allege an actual crime by Trump.  Neither “Abuse of Power” nor “Obstruction of Congress” appear anywhere in the statute books.  They are more akin to the amorphous “collusion” Trump was accused of and which Mr. Mueller spent two years investigating.  There too, the people who were pursuing Trump could never cite a section of the U.S. Code for you.  What Trump did, according to them, was just “wrong” somehow.

          Impeachment is a little different, however.  There are actual consequences (removal from office), should the impeachers succeed.  The entire procedure is based in the Constitution, unlike whatever it was Mueller was doing.  Also, we have a history to refer to---three previous impeachments (or attempts).

          The significance of this history is that on all three previous occasions, the president was accused of a crime.  In Andrew Johnson’s case, Congress had passed a law barring Johnson from dismissing cabinet members he didn’t like, and he dismissed one anyway.  The law was almost certainly unconstitutional, but it was a law and Johnson broke it.

          In Nixon’s case, his resignation ended all impeachment proceedings, but he was credibly accused of having a role in the Watergate burglary.  This would have been a crime even if his role were merely as an accessory after the fact for covering up the break-in.

          Finally, Bill Clinton committed (at least), perjury for lying under oath in a deposition.  Arkansas suspended him from practicing law for five years and assessed a $25,000 fine.  He was also held in contempt by the judge in the Paula Jones case and fined $90,686.

          But since no crime has been alleged against Trump in the impeachment articles, the current proceeding is a case of first impression.  The question is whether a president can be impeached for conduct that is not criminal.  And the answer is nowhere near as difficult or complex as the various partisans are making it out to be.

          The first step is to examine the controlling law, which appears in Article II, Section 4 of the Constitution:

“The President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.”

In the interpretation of a statute or a contract or other document, judges use certain established “rules of construction” to determine the meaning of the language used.  The first, most basic, of these rules is that the plain language that is used will control the judge’s decision unless there is some ambiguity in that language.  Here, what is the ambiguity?  Treason and Bribery are the specific examples used, so the normal interpretation of “other high Crimes and Misdemeanors” would be that they would have to be similar to Treason and Bribery.  The word “other” in this context must mean that Treason and Bribery are themselves high Crimes and Misdemeanors, and that “other” impeachable offenses must share some qualities with the specific examples.  What are those qualities?

          Since Treason and Bribery are both crimes, the minimum requirement must be that “other” offenses should be, at least, crimes.  And that is supposed to end the inquiry.  If the language of a statute is unambiguous, no outside commentary is admissible.

          But despite the absence of ambiguity in the language, those who claim there is no requirement of a criminal act nevertheless insist on bringing in outside commentary to interpret Art. II, Sec. 4.  They should not be permitted to do this, but let’s assume they can, and consider their argument.  It’s easy to do because there is only one piece of commentary they cite, and I have seen and heard it cited dozens of times in the past few days.  It is two sentences from Federalist Paper No. LXV, written in 1787 or 1788 by Alexander Hamilton:

“The subject of its [impeachment] jurisdiction are those offenses which proceed from the misconduct of public men, or, in other words, from the abuse or violation of some public trust.  They are of a nature which may with peculiar propriety be denominated POLITICAL, as they relate chiefly to injuries done immediately to the society itself.”

The capitalized word appears that way in the original, and it is apparently the only thing the anti-Trump forces like about Federalist Paper No. LXV, because it is the entire basis of their argument.  “See,” they claim, “Hamilton says impeachment is all POLITICAL, which means the offense doesn’t have to be a crime, it just has to be some political behavior that we deem improper.”

          The problem with that argument, however, is that these two sentences do not really contradict the words of Art. II, Sec. 4, but can be easily reconciled with the Constitutional language.  Why can’t they mean that the impeachable behavior must be not merely a crime but a POLITICAL crime, (like Treason and Bribery, for example)?  Hamilton’s use of the word “offenses” also supports this interpretation.  “Offenses,” when lawyers are talking about legal law things, means activities that violate the law.  It does not simply mean something that “offends” you, or annoys Nancy Pelosi.

          (We have been here before, or at least part of the way here.  During the Clinton impeachment, the issue was not whether he had committed a crime, because he surely had, but whether his crime was POLITICAL.  When you lie under oath about screwing the chick in the mail room, is that a “high” crime?  Is it POLITICAL?  The argument for Bill Clinton was that, though he had committed a crime, it was not a crime that had anything to do with the nation or his high office or the body politic.  That was the argument made by Alan Dershowitz on Clinton’s behalf.  It was a good argument and it must have held some sway because Clinton was not convicted.)

          But let’s not get distracted.  Let’s get back to the argument from the two sentences of Federalist No. LXV, the argument that the offense for which a president is impeached need not be a crime.  It's not very convincing to begin with, but it falls apart completely another six paragraphs into the essay.

          The criminal/non-criminal issue is settled, definitively, in the eighth paragraph of Federalist No. LXV.   Here, Hamilton describes the consequences of conviction and its aftermath:

“[T]he punishment which may be the consequence of conviction upon impeachment is not to terminate the chastisement of the offender.  After having been sentenced to a perpetual ostracism from the esteem and confidence and honors and emoluments of his country, he will still be liable to prosecution and punishment in the ordinary course of law.”  (Emphasis added.)

        And that settles it.  According to Hamilton, criminal prosecution is something that every impeached person may face, and that could not be true unless every impeachable offense was itself a criminal act.  Note in particular that Hamilton does not say the impeached officer “may” be liable to prosecution.  He says the person “will” be liable to prosecution.

          The analysis above is not difficult or complex.  Any dispassionate lawyer of moderate skill who spent ten minutes reviewing the relevant texts would come to the same conclusion I have.  Yet, as the leftist news media has repeatedly trumpeted, most “constitutional experts” have concluded that impeachment of a president does not require an allegation that the president has committed a crime.  All this means, apparently, is that the majority of what the media call “constitutional experts” are simply partisans and hacks who hate Trump.

Copyright2020MichaelKubacki      

Monday, January 20, 2020

GUNS IN RICHMOND


          Drones were banned, streets and roads were closed, thousands of yards of chain link fencing was erected, dozens of metal detectors were brought in.  The State Police, the Capitol Police, the Richmond Police and the FBI combined to create what was described as a “huge police presence.”  A State of Emergency was declared by Governor Blackface.  Even guns were banned in the Capitol area (at a gun rally!).  The authorities found a few “neo-nazis” a couple hundred miles away, so they were arrested, of course.

          And then, on January 20, a day Virginia traditionally designates as a day for lobbying and protest at the state capitol, 20,000 or so supporters of the 2nd Amendment to the U.S. Constitution showed up because they did not want the legislature to pass some gun laws that would instantly turn many of them into felons.  They carried signs.  They expressed their opinions.

          And nothing happened.

          Nothing bad, anyway.  Nobody got shot.  Nobody got arrested.  There were not even any fistfights apparently, because if there had been, one of the hundreds of journalists who had very little to do would have filmed it for us.

          The idea that legal gun-owners would create a sea of mayhem in the streets of Richmond was absurd.  It was always absurd, no matter how often the Governor and his various subordinates howled about how dangerous the rally was or how worried he was that WWIII would erupt.  They wasted millions of dollars on this “security” show, though there will be no rush, of course, to tell the people of Virginia exactly how much was spent on helicopters and armored vehicles and rooftop snipers and all the other trappings of the police state that leftists like Northam invariably set up whenever they come to power.

          Whenever I go to a gun show, it always occurs to me at some point that I am probably in the safest place in Pennsylvania at that moment.  You are surrounded by weaponry and millions of rounds of ammunition, and people who know how to use it, but they are decent folks.  They are law-abiding citizens.  Many of them, like many of the people in Richmond today, are concealed-carry permit holders, and the crime rate of concealed-carry holders is quite a bit lower than the crime rate of policemen.  The crime rate of carry-permit holders is comparable to the crime rate of nuns, and the crime rate of nuns is quite low.  It’s one of the things they’re known for.

          The danger we face as Americans is not from gun-owners or carry-permit holders or supporters of the U.S. Constitution.  The danger we face comes from those, like Governor Northam, whose ideology makes them so blind to reality and so out of touch with the values held by at least half their fellow citizens, that they are simply unfit to hold important public office.

          [Update.  It is now reported that one person was arrested at the rally for wearing a mask, which suggests she was antifa, or a counter-protester of some kind.]

Copyright2020MichaelKubacki

Saturday, January 18, 2020

ELIZABETH WARREN---Part 2



Pride should be reserved for something you achieve or obtain on your own, not something that happens by accident of birth.  You don’t say, “I’m proud to be 5’10” or “I’m proud to have a predisposition for colon cancer." ---George Carlin

          My prior article dealt with Warren’s September 2018 attempt to put her embarrassing racial history story behind her.  With the help of writer Annie Linskey, the Boston Globe, and many of her colleagues at Harvard Law School, Ms. Warren tried to persuade us that, though she claimed to be a Cherokee at the exact moment it was becoming really, really cool in academia to be a Cherokee, her claims had no bearing on her being hired as a professor at Harvard Law.

          Based on my research on who gets hired at Harvard Law, the conclusion was inescapable: there was no way Warren was hired on her merits.  The ONLY reason she got the job was that she misrepresented her racial identity.  Except for her supposed Indian ancestry, she would never have been hired, would never have become a US Senator, and would not now be taken seriously as a presidential candidate.

          I dislike this woman, I have many good reasons to dislike her, and I’m going to tell you what they are.  The first reason, which grows out of her 1992 hiring at Harvard Law, is that she is a fraud.  Elizabeth Warren could have had a nice career as a lawyer or as a law professor at a school nobody ever heard of.  Everyone says she’s a good teacher, and there’s nothing wrong with being a good teacher.

          But that wasn’t enough.  The ruthlessly ambitious Warren decided, at the threshold of the diversity era, that she could use her “family stories” and “high cheekbones” to catapult herself into the limelight, and so she did.

          There was a tiny window in our history when it was possible to do this, and she took full advantage of it.  “Diversity” in academia became an essential virtue in the early 1990s, at a time when the only DNA testing available cost a lot of money and was used only for criminal prosecutions and paternity disputes.  DNA testing did not become available to consumers for another twenty years.  In was within this period that Elizabeth Warren proclaimed she was a Cherokee, and there was no practical way to challenge her assertions.
  
          In addition to the Boston Globe article, the other initiative in her attempt to put the racial identity issue behind her was the release of a DNA test done for her by Carlos Bustamante, a professor at Stanford.  He concluded that a Native American ancestor appears in Warren’s family tree “in the range of 6-10 generations ago.”  In other words, Warren could possibly be 1/64th Indian, meaning that a great-great-great-great grandparent (born sometime in the early 1800s), might have been Indian.  Or it might have been ten generations, making her 1/1024th part Indian, with an Indian great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great grandparent, probably born in the mid-1700s.*

          This is one reason why tribal councils don’t care about DNA (and why the Cherokees were so annoyed with Warren).  If you want to be a recognized member of a tribe, they insist on proof of descent from a known tribal ancestor, and you must demonstrate it with birth and marriage records.  The other reason, of course, is that Native Americans see things the way George Carlin did---they don’t like the emphasis on “blood.”  Blood is an accident.  Tribal or clan connections are social links or political links or emotional bonds.  They are choices.  They are based in lived human experience and not just in something you find in a test tube.

          When she released Bustamante’s results, Warren touted them on social media.  Her headline: “Warren reveals test confirming ancestry.”  In a recent rally, Trump had said, “I will give you $1 million, to your favorite charity, paid for by Trump, if you take the test and it shows you’re an Indian.”  Warren now demanded payment.  In Elizabeth Warren’s mind, the test proved she was an Indian.

          Let’s do some math.

          In the first generation back, there are two people.  These are your parents.  In the second generation, there are four more people, then eight, then sixteen and so on.  Add them up.  In the 10th generation back there are 1024 people, for a total of 2046 direct ancestors.  Of these 2046 direct ancestors of Elizabeth Warren in ten generations, ONE of them (somebody in the mid-1700’s), was a real, honest-to-God, 100% American Indian.  The rest of them, the other 2045, were basically as pasty-white as she is, but there was that one, about 270 years ago.  And that makes her a Cherokee.

          Haven’t we been here?  Haven’t we done that?  Is she really insisting on taking us back to the “one-drop rule?”

          Following the OK from the Supreme Court in Plessy v. Ferguson (1886), numerous states passed what were called Jim Crow laws that were applicable only to white people or only to black people.  Their purpose was to prevent Negroes from voting, owning guns, living in certain areas, holding certain types of jobs, etc.

          One problem with laws that affect only certain types of people, however, is that you first need to pass a “racial integrity” law to determine which people are subject to the law and which people are not.  Who is really white and who is really black?  While there were jurisdictions that distinguished among quadroons (one-fourth Negro), octoroons (one-eighth Negro), and other “–roons” for legal purposes, most settled on the one-drop rule, which held that if you were of mixed heritage, you were assigned to the group with the lower social status.  There’s even a word for this rule in genealogical circles---it’s called hypodescent.  Thus, if you had “one drop” of Negro blood, you and all your descendants would forever be Negroes.  This was the law in Virginia, Texas, Arkansas, Mississippi, Alabama, North Carolina, Georgia, Tennessee, Oklahoma, and Louisiana.**

          Of course, in the current academic world, or at least the one Warren inhabited in the early 1990s, being Cherokee gave her an enhanced social status, since universities were desperately seeking people of exotic ethnicity to cement their diversity credentials and discourage students from condemning faculty members as irredeemably racist.  That was the situation at Harvard (demonstrations, Jesse Jackson, etc.), and that’s why she was hired as a law professor.

          Was this fraud?  Well, perhaps.  What she did, exaggerating any evidence of Cherokee heritage in order to advance herself professionally, was certainly nothing to be proud of.  On the other hand, DNA testing was in its infancy and there was no “23 And Me” test on the shelf at every Walmart, so there was no obvious or easy way to test her suspicions.  Viewed in the kindest possible light, Warren may have believed she had some vestige of Cherokee heritage, and then pressed her claim when it became apparent that persuading people she was Native American might be the difference between life as a lecturer at Eastern South Oklahoma State and life as a Professor at Harvard Law School.  If you wish to argue she was merely behaving cynically and opportunistically, I still won’t like her, but I will listen to that argument.

          But this is now a different matter, is it not?  Now that we know her heritage is based on a single ancestor from the 1700s or early 1800s, the insistence that her one drop is “confirmation” of Indian identity puts her in the same intellectual camp as John C. Calhoun, George Wallace and David Duke.  Her ideas of racial identity are identical to theirs.  Elizabeth Warren is a racist.  She believes, and she demands that we believe, that a drop of blood from 200 years ago is a key element in her identity.

          In the quotation at the top of this article, George Carlin was mocking people who are “proud to be Irish” or “proud to be black” or “proud to be Cherokee.”  What is there to be proud of, after all, about accidents of birth and ancestry for which we have no responsibility?

          At one level, the practice is innocuous and silly and harmless.  Why not have a shot of Jameson on St. Patty’s day?  Or dress up in traditional Polish clothes and have a parade on the Parkway to celebrate Thaddeus Kosciuszko, whose name most people can neither spell nor pronounce?  Why not?  What else were you going to do on Sunday afternoon?

          But the shot of Jameson is not really the problem.  The problem is blood politics.  The problem is Auschwitz, lynchings, Rwanda.  The problem is the murder of thousands of Chinese Uyghurs.  One grim lesson of the Twentieth Century is that the modern nation-state now has the technology to kill millions of its own people and, given certain ideologies, will do so with great enthusiasm and efficiency.  This capability makes the dirndls and the salsa dancing and the kielbasa and the leprechauns a lot less cute.

          This is because the evil and the cute bits are both impossible without the fundamental belief that you ARE what your blood says you are.  This is not to say that wearing a dirndl on Kosciuszko Day causes genocide, but it does mean that the belief in blood that gives rise to Kosciuszko Day is also an essential component of genocide.  In order to commit genocide, you need to believe that a Jew (a Uyghur, a Cherokee, a whatever), is primarily, and eternally, a member of that group, rather than an individual with unique characteristics, hopes, beliefs, and value.  If you do not believe that all those hated people are basically the same, genocide is impossible.  In a world of individuals rather than geno-types, genocide no longer makes sense.

          The alternative to Warren’s blood politics (“identity politics,” as she might call them), is found in the Declaration.  “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights….”  This belief is the philosophical foundation of the American experiment and the American republic---that at the most fundamental level of human existence, of life and death and joy and suffering, we are NOT Cherokees and we are NOT Poles or Jews or Mexicans or Rwandans.  We’re just a bunch of “funny-looking people looking for God and trying to make a living,” as my father once put it.  All of us.
 
Copyright2020MichaelKubacki          

*The ancestor, by the way, was not necessarily a Cherokee, as Warren has always claimed.  Because of tribal movement, intermarriage and the chaos introduced by the arrival of Europeans, there is no such thing as an identifiable Cherokee DNA.  There is only a broader category of Native American DNA, which does not identify a particular tribe but which is clearly distinguishable from European DNA.

**A variation on the rule [an oddly ironic one, in this context], was Virginia’s Pocahontas Exception, which provided that you were still considered white even if you were up to 1/16 Indian.  This was because many prominent Virginia families claimed descent from Pocahontas and her husband John Rolfe, an early Virginia farmer.