Friday, January 19, 2024

2024 NFL PLAYOFFS—Division Week


I was 2-4 in Wildcard Week, and I was fundamentally wrong about all the games except the first and the last, so now I’m due for a comeback, right?  Right?


 

Houston @ Baltimore (-9.5)

 

          Houston’s first game of the 2023 season was C.J. Stroud’s NFL debut, a 25-9 loss to the Baltimore Ravens.  He went 28/44 for 242 yards with no interceptions.  It was not a terrible performance.  Throughout the season, he didn’t have many bad performances.  The worst was in a 30-6 loss to the stinkin’ Jets on December 10, where he went 10/23 for 91 yards (but with no interceptions).  Even though he was a rookie, the worst you ever got from him was mediocrity.  And the best you got from him was brilliant.  Stroud played close to a perfect game against the Browns this week: 16/21 for 274 yards and no interceptions.  His AYP for that game was 13.0.

 

         Baltimore is better, of course.  Lamar Jackson’s possible MVP season has laid to rest the idea that he was an entertaining sideshow but not really a top-level NFL QB.  It has taken a while, but his AYP of 7.1 is right up there with Tua (and Stroud).  The Ravens had the NFL’s best record, an 8-0 record in blow-outs, and outscored their opponents by 11.9 points per game.  Baltimore also showed the 2nd best defensive AYP (behind only Cleveland).

 

         One must expect the Ravens to win this game, and probably their next one as well, but Houston with Stroud as QB has matured as a team and will remain competitive throughout the game.  Stroud has thrown only five interceptions all year and he doesn’t make the kind of “rookie mistakes” that rookies make, so I don’t envision the sort of melt-down that turns into a blow-out.  I’m taking Houston with the points.


 

         Green Bay @ San Francisco (-10)

 

            The standard wisdom among the NFL brainiac commentariat is that Green Bay’s Thanksgiving Day victory over Detroit changed their entire season and perhaps ripped apart the very matrix itself.   They’re different now.  Jordan Love has come into his own, the lark is on the wing and the snail is on the thorn.  Or something.

 

I dunno.

 

First, I don’t think you can call the Packer victory on Thanksgiving a dominant performance.  They were outgained 464 yards to 377 and seemed to get every break they needed.  Detroit went 0-fer on their 4th down tries, Goff fumbled three times (one of which was run back for a TD), and the Lions seemed to be out of sync all day.  It was also their 7th consecutive loss on Thanksgiving Day, whatever that means.

 

And it’s not like the Pack rolled through the rest of their schedule.  Two weeks later they lost to the NY Giants and the week after that to Tampa Bay.  Then on Christmas Eve, the Pack eked out a win over the 2-13 Panthers in a game where Carolina gained more yards.  Then admittedly, they played well against Minnesota and Chicago.  Then came the Cowgirls.

 

I picked the Girls in that game.  I was all over the Girls.  I thought they would win by 30.  And when I look at it now, my only thought is: “Well, why didn’t they win by thirty???”   There is a saying at the racetrack: “Sometimes you handicap it right and they just run it wrong.”   And that’s what I’m sticking with here.  The Cowboys collapsed because they are morally corrupt, because they are owned by Jerry Jones, and because no matter how well Dak “Don’t Call Me Dakota” Prescott plays during the season, he will always be a mutt. 

 

The Packers played well.  Jordan Love played well, and God bless him.  But I still don’t think the Packers belong here.

 

Looking at my numbers, I don’t remember ever seeing a mismatch like this in a playoff game.  SF’s AYP is 8.1; the Packer’s is 6.3.  The defensive AYP for San Fran is a full two yards better than Green Bay’s.  The 49ers outscored their opponents by 11.3 points while the Packers barely outscored their opponents at all.  Green Bay had three blowout wins and three blowout losses, while the 49ers had 11 blowout wins, most in the league.

 

I also think there is a revenge play at work here, though it doesn’t involve the Packers.

 

Last year, San Francisco came to Philadelphia for the NFC Championship game and though the Eagles were favored slightly, I don’t think there is any doubt the 49ers thought they were the best team in the NFC and were going to the Superbowl.

 

Then they got mugged.  Brock Purdy got his elbow twisted in the first half and then the Eagles delivered a concussion to his backup.  Maybe the Eagles were better and maybe they weren’t, but San Francisco left Philly believing they had been jobbed, and I expect they still feel bitter about it. So not only are they good, I think they’re angry too.

 

San Francisco will win this game and register its 12th blowout of the season.  Lay the points.


 

Tampa Bay @ Detroit (-6.5)

 

Neither one of these teams is great, but one of them will be playing in the NFC Championship Game.  And I don’t know which it will be.

 

Their numbers are similar, down the line.  Detroit’s AYP is 6.6 and Tampa’s is 6.2.   Defensive AYP is identical.  Neither outscored their opponent by much and Detroit blew out six opponents versus Tampa’s four.

 

Detroit scored 461 points during the season and Tampa scored 348, and as a guy who likes offense in playoff games, I guess that strikes me as a meaningful difference. 

 

This line strikes me as accurate, and the sensible gambler passes the game.  I’ll take Detroit and lay the points, but my confidence level on this one is zero.


 

Kansas City @ Buffalo (-2.5) 

 

The December 10 matchup between these two was played at Arrowhead, and the Bills escaped with a 20-17 win when Kansas City’s winning TD in the final minute was called back for an offside penalty.  The game was close throughout with neither team clearly dominant.

 

Buffalo is a wee bit better in all the categories I look at: a larger point differential, more blowouts, a better AYP and a better pass defense.  Neither Mahomes nor Allen are near the top of the QB list this year but that doesn’t mean they can’t win a big playoff game.

 

The line reflects a little too much respect for KC and Andy Reid and being the defending Superbowl champion and having more players with lucrative commercial deals than Buffalo does.  And maybe Taylor Swift knocks the line down a half-point as well.

 

The game’s in Buffalo and the Bills are slightly superior, so I think the line should be more than 2.5.  I’m laying those points.

 

Copyright2024MichaelKubacki  

 

Friday, January 12, 2024

2024 NFL PLAYOFFS---Wildcard Week

          I refer the reader to previous articles on my NFL playoff predictions for the philosophy that guides me.  In a nutshell, the teams that win the NFL playoffs are teams that can complete long passes.  The best defensive teams rarely win.  Teams with run-based offenses never win.  What you have to do to win a Superbowl is throw the ball down the field.

           For this reason, my primary tool is a number I call AYP, or “adjusted yards per pass.”  This is the number of yards gained passing during the season divided by the number of passes thrown, and adjusted downward for the number of interceptions thrown.  A very good team will have an AYP over 7 for the season.  An AYP of 6 is pretty good.  Teams with an AYP under 5 do not play games in the month of February.


          Since AYP can also be calculated for a team’s pass defense, I do so, mostly so I can look at the extremes: who has a really good pass defense, and who has a bad one.    I also glance at point differentials over the course of the season.


          Finally, I note how each playoff team did in blowouts (defined as a game decided by 11 or more points), during the season.  When one good team beats another good team with a last-second field-goal, I’m not always sure what it means.  But when a good team beats another NFL team by 28, it tells me something.


We start with the three categories of teams.


I used to define PRETENDERS as those teams unlikely to win a game in the tournament, but now that there are 14 teams in the playoffs, a few bad teams may get past the first week.  They have no shot at the Superbowl, however.  This year, the pretenders are Cleveland, Kansas City, Pittsburgh, Tampa Bay, Philadelphia, the Rams, and the Packers.


In the COULD GET LUCKY category, we put the teams that “nobody wants to play.”  They do not look good enough to challenge the elite squads at the top of the standings, but they have done “something,” they have surprised people, and they have some of the offensive firepower that can make up for a lot of flaws.  This year, I put Houston and Detroit in this box.


The remaining five CONTENDERS are the teams with a realistic shot at the enchilada: Baltimore, Buffalo, Miami, San Fran and Dallas.


Cleveland @ Houston (+2.5)

 

I listed Houston as a COULD GET LUCKY team, and maybe that’s a bit of a stretch.  They did get blown out four times this year, by Baltimore, Indy, the stinkin’ Jets, and Cleveland.  However, the biggest number I’m looking at is Houston’s AYP of 7.0 vs. Cleveland’s 4.6.


Cleveland fans---who are they, anyway?  have you ever actually met one?--- will point out that the Browns’s last five games under the apparently-still-alive Joe Flacco have changed everything, and it is true that Flacco’s AYP for those games is 6.0.  On the other side, however, Houston’s passing stats were pulled downward by the performances of Case Keenum and several other non-entities.   C.J. Stroud, who will be facing Cleveland, is actually quite wonderful.  His AYP for Houston this year was 7.7 and his QB rating was 100.8, which is in the same neighborhood as Prescott, Jackson, and Tagovailoa.


Houston is getting points at home, and they should be favored.  The Texans will win outright.

 

Miami @ KC (-3.5) 

 

The football Gods have not been kind to the Miami Dolphins in the playoffs.  Last year, Tua’s brain was broken so the league wouldn’t let him play against the Bills.   This year, various Miami players, including a bunch of linebackers, spent the holiday season getting mutilated so the Dolphins head into the playoffs at their lowest ebb of the season.

 

Based on the numbers from the season, Miami dominates this matchup, with an AYP of 7.0 vs. K.C.’s 5.6.  Tua’s NFL passer rating is 101.1 this year, compared to Mahomes’s 92.6.  The Chief’s defense, including their pass defense, is stronger than Miami’s, especially after the Miami injuries, but K.C. and Mahomes are not scaring anybody.  They were 5 – 5 over their last ten games.

 

In other words, the numbers say Miami but the injuries say K.C.  I’m taking the Dolphins here because they are getting points and because the Chiefs this year are nothing special.  However, I have little confidence Miami will win the game.

 

Take the points.

 

Pittsburgh @ Buffalo (-10)


Mason “The Reindeer” Rudolph has been a Steeler since 2019 but never made much of an impression on anybody.  He then started the last three games of this season, and beat the Bengals 34-11, the Seahawks 30-23, and the Ravens 10-7.  During this brief stretch, he threw 74 passes, completed 55 of them (74.3%), and gained 719 yards with no interceptions for a QB rating of 118.0 and an AYP of 9.7.

 

I’m not saying he’s Joe Montana and I’m not saying he won’t crash and bleed out on the frozen expanse in Buffalo on Sunday.  But what is he facing?

 

I list Buffalo as a CONTENDER because they were 5-0 in blowouts and outscored their opponents by an average of 8 points per game.  There were six teams that scored more than 450 points this year, and the Bills (451) were one of them.  Also, after splitting their first twelve games, they won their last five, so they’re going in the right direction.

 

But as the seasons pile up, it is becoming clear that Josh Allen is a decent quarterback who is probably good enough, with a terrific team around him, to win a championship, but who rarely scintillates.  Buffalo’s AYP was 5.9, the same as Pittsburgh’s, and miles behind Baltimore, Houston, and Miami.  Allen’s QB rating for the season was 92.2, which is 16th on the list of QBs who started double-digit games.

 

A Pittsburgh win here would be a shock, of course, and I’m not predicting it, but the line should be a field goal or so.  Based on the excitement the Reindeer  brings to the Steeler side and the fact that Buffalo and Allen are just nothing special, I’m taking the points.

 

Green Bay @ Dallas (-7.5)

 

This one is for all you chalk lovers.  

 

The numbers are persuasive.  The AYP for the Girlz is 6.8, compared to the Pack’s 6.3.  Prescott’s QB rating of 105.9 was second only to San Fran’s Purdy.  Dallas’s pass defense is also far superior to the Pack’s, which probably has the worst pass defense among all the NFC playoff teams.  Dallas blew out nine teams; Green Bay only 3.  In doing so, the Girlz scored 509 points, most in the NFL. 

 

Finally, the game is in Dallas, where the Cowboys went 8-0 this season, outscoring their opponents by 21.5 points per game.  To get to the Superbowl, they will probably have to go through San Fran, but until that happens, it will be hard to doubt the Cowboys.

 

Expect a scoring party in the Big D, and lay the points.

 

L.A. Rams @ Detroit (-3)

 

Well, there’s certainly all kinds of symmetries and synchronicities here, and other things that start with the “s” sound.  The Rams dumped Goff a few years ago because they just didn’t like him much, and he now gets to start for Detroit in a playoff game against them.  Goff has had a good but maybe not spectacular season, and he would probably like to win this game.  He has reportedly spent the last week sticking pins in a voodoo doll of Rams Coach Sean McVay.

 

Then there is Stafford, who played in Detroit for 12 years but never played a playoff game there.  Now, after winning the 2-13-22 Superbowl for the Rams, he gets to come back to the Motor City and try to get his team past the Wildcard round.

 

Looking at the overall numbers for the season, one would give Detroit a small edge.  The Lion’s AYP is 6.8; the Rams’ is 6.3.  Pass defense also favors Detroit, which also blew out six teams vs. four for the Rams.

 

The argument for the Rams has two major points: 1) Stafford owns a Superbowl ring (though his numbers this year are middle-of-the-pack), and 2) after starting the season 3-6, L.A. won seven of their last eight.

 

I look at the stretch of wins for the Rams, however, and I don’t see a lot of dominating performances.  From that I conclude they have gotten their act together and are now much more competitive than they were back in September and October, but I don’t view them as the proverbial “team nobody wants to play.”

 

In the interest of making a pick here, I’ll lay the points with Detroit.  I’m in a playoff pool with a dozen other maniacs, and I’ll take Detroit in that pool because I have to take somebody, but this is the game in which I have no confidence in my selection.

 

Philly @ Tampa (+3)

 

Please see my blog post of January 4 for the full story of the Philadelphia collapse in 2023-24.  At the end of this season, I expect the entire coaching staff, including head coach Nick Sirianni, will be fired.

 

After starting 10-1, the Birds lost five of their last six games and were outscored by 10 ppg during that stretch.  Despite continuing statements that “we’re working on this” and “we’re going to fix this,” the Eagles changed nothing during that period, running the same plays, calling the same defenses week after week, and getting the same results.

 

Even if you look at the entire Eagles season, however, including the 10-1 part, the Bucs still have posted better numbers.  Tampa is no threat to anybody in the playoffs, and they will certainly be eliminated next week, but they are good enough to win this game.  Tampa’s AYP is higher than the Eagles’, and Baker Mayfield has had a better season statistically than Jalen Hurts.

 

Tampa Bay wins outright.

 

Copyright2024MichaelKubacki

 

Addendum:  There are always a few factoids I discover in the course of writing this that I have no convenient place to insert.  Here’s some:

1)   Travis Kelce is paid $20 million a year by Pfizer, and only $14 million by the Chiefs.

2)   As part of its latest campaign to persuade America that it only makes beer for manly men and doesn’t really support people who want to castrate little boys and cut the breasts off 14-year-old girls, Bud Light’s new, very-well-compensated NFL endorsers are Dak Prescott (Dallas), Travis Kelce (K.C.), and George Kittle (SF).

3)   As far as I can tell, Travis Kelce is the only celebrity endorser for both Pfizer and Bud Light.  I suspect he is also in negotiations to do commercials for Hamas and the makers of Zyklon B.

Tuesday, January 9, 2024

INSURRECTION

The U.S. Supreme Court has taken an appeal from the decision of the Colorado Supreme Court banning Donald Trump from the Colorado presidential primary because he engaged in insurrection on January 6, 2021.  Colorado held a “trial” of sorts to determine that an insurrection occurred and that Trump engaged in it.  The state of Maine came to the same conclusion by an executive decree, without a trial or other legal process.  Other states are considering barring Trump from their ballots as well.  Oral arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court will be made on February 8, and it is expected a decision will follow soon thereafter.

 

My initial reaction to the news that SCOTUS would take up the issue was that this was likely to be a 9 – 0 ruling in favor of Trump.  To my mind, the idea that the protesters on January 6, none of whom had guns, could be said to have engaged in an “insurrection” was a sort of Trump-Derangement-Syndrome fever-dream.  When a case like this gets to the Supreme Court, as it does on rare occasions, the one or two leftwing partisan hacks will sometimes see how useless it is to assert, reflexively, their progressive ideals.  At that point, they join the majority.  This gives them a piece of evidence they can later assert.  “See.  I’m an actual judge.  I sometimes read and follow the law.” 

 

This is why there was a unanimous ruling in McDonnell v. United States, 579 US 550 (2016), overturning the conviction for fraud and bribery of Robert F McDonnell, Republican Governor of Virginia.  His political career was over anyway, so even Ginsburg, Kagan, Breyer and Sotomayor joined in dumping the ridiculous charges against him even though he was a Republican.  Another famous instance was the 9 – 0 reversal of Arthur Andersen LLP v. United States, 544 US 696 (2005).  The firm had been (absurdly). convicted of obstruction of justice for covering up the fraud of their client, Enron.  Again, the accounting firm had already been destroyed by the case by the time it got to the SCOTUS, so even the partisan lefties on the Court could join in the decision with no harm to their political agenda.

 

That’s why I initially assumed this Trump case would be decided unanimously.  The other possibility, I thought, was 7 – 2 for Trump with Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown in dissent simply because they would break out in boils and rashes if they were ever to rule in Trump’s favor for anything.

 

But now I’m not so sure.  

 

The relevant sections of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution state:

Section 3

No person shall be a Senator or Representative in Congress, or elector of President and Vice-President, or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States, or under any State, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of Congress, or as an officer of the United States, or as a member of any State legislature, or as an executive or judicial officer of any State, to support the Constitution of the United States, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof. But Congress may by a vote of two-thirds of each House, remove such disability.

Section 5

The Congress shall have the power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.

 

         On first reading, several bits of text jump out immediately.  First, if the intention of Section 3 was to bar an insurrectionist from running for the office of President, why didn’t they specifically list “president” as one of the offices an insurrectionist could not hold?  They say “Senator.”  They say “Representative.”  They say “member of any State legislature.”   Why didn’t they say “President?”  Instead, we have to infer that Trump, by running for President, is 1) running for “any office, civil or military, under the United States” AND that 2) his previous presidential oath in 2017 was taken as “an officer of the United States.”


         In other words, is the President an “officer of the United States?”  Why make this so complicated?  Why make this something for us to argue about 160 years after the Amendment was passed instead of just specifying “President?”

 

         In fact, this was the central issue in the Colorado case.  A lower-court judge had found that Trump had engaged in an “insurrection,” but decided that Section 3 did not apply to him because Section 3 did not specify it applied to a President.  The Colorado Supreme Court reversed the lower court on this point, ruling 4 – 3 that Trump, as President, was an “officer of the United States.” 


         I’m not going to analyze this question for you.  To decide what “officer of the United States” means, you have to go back and figure out, from arguments in Congress in the 1860s, what the term meant to them.  And that depends, to some extent, on what “officer” meant during the arguments on the original Constitution, drafted in 1788.


         Personally, I take what I think is the more obvious and likely path---that you can’t assume “President” when they could easily have specified “President” but chose not to.  However, there is a legitimate argument about what was meant.  There have been law review articles written on this question and they were not written by AOC and Kamala Harris.  This is not like finding a “right to abortion” in the Constitution that was sitting there for 200 years but nobody had noticed it before.  They’re not just making it up as they go along.


         The next question that arises is the meaning of the “self-executing” provision in Section 5.  This same provision appears in the 13th, 14th, 15th, 18th, 19th, 23rd, 24th, and 25th amendments, and is generally held to mean that these amendments need fleshing out with rules and procedures, so Congress has the power to do that.  In the case of the “insurrection” clause in Section 3, the argument on Trump’s side is that a court in Colorado cannot simply decide that what Trump did was “engage in an insurrection.”  (And neither, presumably, can an executive officer in the Maine government.)


         Even here, though, there is a legitimate argument to be made that no such congressional assistance is needed.  Following the Civil War, the Fourteenth Amendment was used for about four years (until an amnesty was declared in 1872), and a number of men who had served in the Confederacy were barred from holding office in southern states.  The procedure for doing this was---well, there was no procedure and no legal process.  They were summarily dismissed from the ballot by election authorities.  At the time, of course, there was no real factual issue about who had been engaged in an insurrection, and no real need for “due process.”  The extent of it would be, “Yo, Beauregard.  You were a colonel under General Lee, weren’t you?  Well, sorry.  You can’t run for sheriff.”


         The effect of this history is that, during the period Section 3 was actually used to keep some insurrectionists off the ballot, the provision was self-executing.  Nobody looked to Congress for definitions or procedures, so if some local official in 2024 wants to rule that Trump engaged in insurrection, there’s precedent for him having the power to do that.  Leftist partisans on the Supreme Court will be aware of this argument and will use it to justify Trump being declared an insurrectionist without a helluva lot of procedure or testimony or debate.


         All of which suggests to me that some context needs to be taken into consideration if we wish to avoid absurd results.


         Let’s start here: the “insurrection” they were thinking about when the 14th Amendment became law was a four year conflagration in the American republic where more than a million men suited up for battle against their countrymen, and where more than a million Americans were killed in battle, in accidents, by disease, in prison camps, and by all the other horrific ways people die in an all-out existential war.  For this, the Amendment barred insurrectionists from the Confederacy from holding elective office, for a while.


         By contrast, the “insurrection” that Trump is alleged to have engaged in occurred on one day, January 6, 2021, and sought to delay the certification of electoral votes in Congress from the 2020 election.  The insurrectionists, none of whom brought firearms, did damage to property and injured several police officers, though none fatally.  Several of the rioters vandalized office areas of elected officials they believed had stolen the election, and one of them put his feet on Nancy Pelosi’s desk.


         Beyond the vastly differing nature of the “insurrections” of 1861 and 2021, the other point to be made about the self-executing nature of the 14th Amendment is that Congress eventually did exercise its “power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.”  It did so by passing the Insurrection Act in 1948, which is found in the U.S. Code at 18 USC 2383. It is a criminal statute which provides for fines and prison for anyone found to have engaged in an insurrection.  It also provides that a person convicted may not run for elective office.  Neither Trump nor any of the thousand people charged with crimes in connection with the January 6 riot have even been charged with violating the Insurrection Act.


         This argument was made by one of the dissenting justices on the Colorado Supreme Court, and it will be the grounds on which the case is decided at the Supreme Court.  In a 6-3 or 5-4 decision, the Court will rule that Congress passed the Insurrection Act in order to enforce the provisions of Section 3, so a conviction under the Insurrection Act is a prerequisite for barring someone from running for office.  This is the easiest possible ruling for the majority on the Court.  It is also the smallest possible ruling in the sense that it will have the least possible effect on other existing laws.  The Supreme Court never likes to make more law than it has to.


         (The other issue that is an ice-cold winner for the Trump side is the free speech argument it presented in Colorado, asserting that the First Amendment permitted Trump to say what he said about stolen elections.  The Colorado Supreme Court opinion on this point is based on the “imminent danger” doctrine of Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969), and they get Brandenburg so wrong you have to wonder if they even read it.  Since the SCOTUS does not have to reach this issue, however, they won’t bother.)


         The Supreme Court will overturn the Colorado decision and it will do so in such a way that all the other challenges to Trump in other states will disappear as well.   They can do this by ruling that insurrectionists are only those people who have been convicted under the Insurrection Act---in other words, nobody. 


         But the lefties on the Court will not go along for the ride.  They have decent arguments they can make in dissent, and more importantly, this is not the McDonnell case or the Arthur Andersen case, where the Left had no real investment in the issues by the time those cases got to the SCOTUS.


         Here, there’s Trump, and their heads will explode if they participate in a Trump victory in any way.


         More importantly, there’s an even larger issue at stake here.  For the elites on the Left, the assault on dissent of all kinds is a global campaign.  We first witnessed it in COVID “misinformation” campaigns around the world, where respected epidemiologists and other scientists were censored and de-platformed and had their professional licenses revoked for challenging the official pandemic narrative.  We have also seen opposing voices silenced by the transexual-medical industry, and by the DEI forces in industry and on campus.  Most recently, we have seen any opposition to Jew-hatred met with violence by pro-Hamas demonstrators and academics.  Our old-fashioned ideals of free speech were designed merely to prop up the fascist establishment, we are told.  Dissent from accepted leftist views is “dangerous,” and one thing Trump regularly does is dissent from accepted leftist views, so he must be silenced.


         The insistence that only “approved” candidates be permitted to run for office is part of this campaign.   We would all be so much safer, you see, if only decent, non-colonialist, anti-racist progressives (preferably people of color) could be elected to office.   Getting Trump thrown off the ballot would send an unmistakable message: “We’ll pick our candidate and we’ll pick your candidate too, and that’s how it’s going to work from now on.”  That’s why the Left is fighting this battle.


Copyright2024MichaelKubacki      

Thursday, January 4, 2024

The 2023 EAGLES NIGHTMARE---A Playoff Prequel

         As I write this, the last games of the 2023-24 NFL regular season are two days away, and my Eagles are in full meltdown.  Many explanations have been offered for why this has happened, and many of them are at least partially true.  This is my explanation.

 

On December 2, the Philadelphia Eagles were 10 – 1, with wins over Dallas, Miami, Kansas City, Buffalo and the LA Rams.  One month later, on January 2, they had lost four out of five, and had been blown out twice.  They had appeared to be on a path to the Superbowl, or at least to the NFC Championship game, but now they seem much more likely to be eliminated in the first round of the playoffs.

 

         The Philly demise would seem to be a sudden and monumental collapse, and that is how it is being treated in the local papers and radio.  “The league caught on.”  “Hurts is injured but is trying to keep it together.”  “Head Coach Sirianni has been unable to adjust to the way other teams are playing the Eagles now.”  Most commentators have blamed the team’s defense, and the Defensive Coordinator was relieved of his play-calling responsibilities two weeks ago.

 

         And, well, it is true the defense has declined (largely as a result of injuries), but it was never world-class to begin with.  It was good enough to get to a Superbowl last year, however, though not quite good enough to win one.

 

         The strength of the team, however, both last year and this, has been the talent on the offensive side of the ball.  With Hurts, DeVonta Smith, A. J. Brown, Dallas Goedert, D’Andre Swift , and a highly-skilled, experienced offensive line, the Eagles had the best offensive squad in the NFL.  (“On paper,” as they say.)   This is not just me saying this.  It was the consensus view among those who know more about such things than I do.  Yet the astonishing thing is that Coach Sirianni and his Offensive Coordinator chose not to use the talent they had.

 

         It was apparent to me and to a few others that even when the Eagles were 10 – 1, they were heading for a fall, simply because the coaches refused to use the talent they had to score points.  The Eagles offense could have scored 40 points against most of the opponents it faced.  They were that good.  Instead, Sirianni and his OC became obsessed with merely possessing the ball.  They fell in love with 19-play drives that take 8 minutes off the clock, as if time of possession (rather than points scored), was the true measure of an offense’s proficiency.  A bizarre folly, but this was Sirianni’s first head-coaching job, and he is surrounded by other very young coaches.  There is no one there who has been around for thirty years and had the prestige to slap Sirianni upside the head.  (“Yo, Nick!  You have A. J. Brown.  Throw the ball to him forty yards down the field and see what happens!”)

 

         The result was that, of those first eleven games, the Eagles only won two of them by double digits.  The rest of them were close, a lot closer than they had to be.    Beat the Patriots 25-20.  Beat Minnesota 34-28.  Beat the Redskins 34-31 in OT.  Lost to the Jets 20-14.  Letting teams like this stick around was ALWAYS going to lead to disaster.  And now it has.

 

         When you have a superior offense, the LAST thing you want is 19-play drives that reduce the number of possessions in the game, yet that was Sirianni’s goal, week after week.  If you reduce the number of possessions, all you do is increase the chance that the weaker team will get lucky and win.  That is why reducing the number of possessions is an underdog strategy.  In the first round of the 1989 NCAA tournament, in the game between #1 seed Georgetown and #16 seed Princeton, it was Princeton that used every second it could (all 45 of them per possession), to slow down the game.  The result was a 50-49 G’town victory in a game in which they were 23-point favorites.

 

         For a football team, the case for speeding up the pace of play and increasing the number of possessions is even stronger than it is in other sports.  One reason for this is that, unlike basketball, the offensive unit and the defensive units are separate squads.  This means that you can, and should, shape the play of the game so as to protect your very expensive offensive skill players from unnecessary mayhem.

 

Put more simply, it is pure idiocy to give a 240-pound defensive lineman nineteen chances to separate your $300-million quarterback’s head from his body.  It makes much more sense to give that low-browed killing machine only three chances per possession to destroy your franchise.   The ideal offensive drive takes three plays, lasts one hundred seconds, covers eighty yards, and scores a touchdown.  There is a place, I suppose, for a three-minute drive that ends in a field goal, but there is a very strong argument that the BEST non-scoring offensive drive takes three plays and ends in a punt. You then sit your billion-dollar offense on the bench, feed them some Gatorade, give them foot massages, and advise them on how best to score when your team gets the ball back.

 

Sirianni, of course, is not the first NFL coach to fall in love with ball-possession football and misunderstand, fundamentally, the nature of the game.  It all started with Bill Parcells.

 

The game that made Parcells a certified genius occurred on January 27, 1991.  This was Superbowl XXV, in which Parcells’s Giants defeated the Buffalo Bills 20-19.

 

The Bills that year featured one of the first no-huddle offenses in the NFL.  They led the league in scoring offense with 428 points.  On the other side, Parcells had a solid team with a good defense, and no real superstars.  This is why the 1990-91 Giants always appear on any list of the “Ten Worst Teams Ever to Win a Superbowl.”

 

In the Superbowl itself, Parcells went full-out Princeton vs. Marv Levy’s Georgetown.  The Giants held the football for 40 minutes and 33 seconds of the game, and sent the Bills to the first of their four consecutive SB defeats when Scott Norwood went ‘Wide Right” in the closing seconds. 

 

(Trivia: a week ago, on December 31, 2023, the 98-year-old Marv Levy attended Buffalo’s 27-21 victory over the Patriots.)

 

The effect on the NFL was instant, and predictable.  It was as if Princeton had actually beaten Georgetown.  Every coach and every owner suddenly realized that the ONLY way to win a Superbowl was to hold on to the football, execute penalty-free and turnover-free 19-play drives, and beat all those other silly coaches and owners who wanted to score sixty points every game.  The fad faded in a few years as it became clear that Parcells had parleyed a unique collection of players and a lot of luck into a championship, and that what he had done was never going to happen very often, but there are still football guys (the ones who don’t really think things through on their own), who can be seduced by time-of-possession theories and do stupid things.  Nick Sirianni is one of those guys.

 

Sirianni was nine years old when Superbowl XXV was played.  It may have been the first Superbowl he ever saw and maybe it had an oversized effect on the development of his youthful football brain.  Though I lack any evidence regarding why he thinks the way he does, that’s my theory.  And since I did have that one psychology course in college, I am fully competent to render such a judgment.

 

Copyright 2024MichaelKubacki  

Tuesday, December 26, 2023

THIS & THAT XXVII

 

         I didn’t hear “Baby It’s Cold Outside” once this season.  For the past few years, it has been discussed and argued about, but there were always a few rebels who would play it on the radio.  Now I think it has been quietly banned because it’s so unsafe and rape-y.

 

*

 

         There is a distinct odor of the 1930’s in the air.

 

         It’s impossible to see the celebrations of the October 7 massacres without thinking of the ships full of Jewish refugees turned away in New York by Roosevelt and sent back to Europe, to their deaths.

 

         When I see the quarantine camps and the COVID lockdowns, and the demonization of healthy citizens who have done nothing wrong, my mind wanders back to the Japanese-American citizens rounded up for internment camps.

 

         And when confused children are seduced into the transgender industry to be sexually mutilated through drugs or surgery, often with the enthusiastic participation of their parents, how can we not be reminded of the eugenics movement sterilizing tens of thousands of “inferior” people?

 

*

 

         Southwest Airlines has announced its new “person of size” policy, which gives free seats to people who need more space because their butt can’t fit in the one seat they purchased.  One way they can take advantage of the policy is to purchase two adjoining seats, fly to wherever, and then demand a refund of half their fare.

 

         Here’s my question.  What if I merely identify as a “person of size” but weigh 160 pounds?  Can I too pay for one seat and get two?  What if I am fat only in my mind?  What if I’m a fathead?

 

*

 

         COVID trivia: though the virus is not nearly as dangerous as it once was, there are still elderly people with serious illnesses for whom COVID can be life-threatening.  Some doctors prescribe nicotine pills for these patients.

 

         COVID enters the body through “receptors,” which are present on human cells.  The virus can bind with certain receptors and thus infect the person.  One type of receptor that the COVID virus typically uses is the ACE2 receptor, but there are others.

 

         For tobacco users, the ACLR receptor is how nicotine gets into the body.  These receptors can also accept COVID virus, but not at the same time.  This is why smokers tend to get fewer COVID infections and have fewer serious or deadly outcomes.  The advantage for smokers was apparent from the beginning of the COVID outbreak.

 

         This is also why nicotine pills are being used (experimentally) as a treatment for COVID in at-risk patients.  The nicotine occupies the ACLR receptors, leaving fewer opportunities for COVID to enter the body.

 

*

 

         A few months ago, I blogged my theories on the Democratic race for the presidential nomination in 2024.  To save you the trouble of reading it, my prediction was that Michelle Obama would be presented as the new figurehead President so that Barack could continue in his role as the national political leader.  He would continue to govern as he has under Biden’s four years, though with Michelle as the front man.  The pretense that someone other than Barack was president could thus be abandoned.  While there are people now who believe Biden is a real president who makes policy, nobody would believe Michelle was anything other than a stand-in.  Michelle in the Oval Office would simplify matters.

 

         There is still no question Biden will be replaced.  He’s like that 1993 Toyota that you love, that is full of memories, but is now beyond fixing.  Are you really going to put a third carburetor in the damn thing.  No.  You’re going to ditch that Tercel.

 

         And I’m not backing off my original prediction since Michelle remains the ideal choice for the Obama machine that rules America.  But Kamala also has a possible path to the top job.

 

         Nobody (or almost nobody) wants her there, and nobody likes her very much, but they chose her as VP partly to get Joe past the finish line, and now they are stuck with her.  She’s young and healthy, and they can’t just kick her out of national politics without some serious howling from the DEI crowd.  I mean, did she somehow STOP being a little bit black and a little bit Asian?  And doesn’t she still own a vagina?

 

         So if they can’t easily dump her, the question becomes how to use her.  Would she accept a secondary role and take orders from Barack?  She might.  Gavin Newsom would not---if he were made president, he would insist on being the boss---but Kamala might take the deal.  Kamala might realize the ONLY way for her to become president is to accept the state-dinner/ice-cream-cone role that Biden now enjoys.  It could work, and it would free Michelle Obama to continue hanging out with her girlfriends on Ibiza and Martha’s Vineyard.

 

*

 

         I understand it is typical for geezers like me to rail against today’s ignorant and misbegotten young folks.  In my defense I can only say that I don’t believe I have ever done that.

 

         Until now.

 

         When I see polls indicating that HALF of Americans aged 18-34 believe the massacres of Israelis on October 7 were justified, or blame the Jews for the killings, I am worried.  When I see tens of thousands of youthful Jew-haters filling the streets around the world violently demonstrating and chanting for the annihilation of Jews, I dread what the future may bring.  

 

         I knew that no real history was being taught to high school and college students, and I knew the group-identity-based indoctrination was taking place, but I had no idea how successful it was, or how many young people were affected, or how thoroughly the Left had purged any consideration of good and evil from the minds of the young. 

 

Copyright2023MichaelKubacki